Concepts
Refactoring, a crucial element of agile development methodologies such as Scrum, centers around altering the structure of the code without altering its external behavior. The primary goal is to facilitate maintainability, enhance readability, and enable easier addition of new features. While it’s essential in the development process, it becomes even more crucial for those aspiring to get certified as an Advanced Certified Scrum Developer (A-CSD).
Basics on Refactoring
Refactoring is essentially editing or reconstructing the code to make it more efficient, cleaner, and easier to comprehend, without altering its function. Often when a codebase is large, complex, or legacy, it becomes challenging to maintain it or understand it without an ample amount of time and resources. This is where refactoring steps in to optimize the code, making it easy to maintain.
In the context of the Scrum framework, refactoring usually takes place in short iterations or sprints, following the principles of Test-Driven Development (TDD). This defines a cycle of first creating a test case, then refactoring until your code passes the test.
A Recommended Approach to Refactoring
Let’s delve into a typical approach that could be used to refactor a system effectively.
Step 1: Identify Areas that Need Refactoring
The first step is to identify code fragments that require refactoring. Code smells, which are essentially patterns in the code that indicate possible issues, can help in identifying such fragments. Examples of code smells include duplication, long methods, large classes, and switch statements. Let’s consider we have identified a ‘Long Method’ code smell for refactoring.
def calculate_total_price(quantity, price_per_unit, discount, tax):
total = quantity * price_per_unit
total = total – (total * discount / 100)
total = total + (total * tax / 100)
return total
In the above exemplary code, a method is performing multiple operations to calculate the total price. It’s a perfect candidate for refactoring as it breaches the single responsibility principle.
Step 2: Build Tests
Before modifying the code base, make sure you have tests that cover the part of the codebase you want to refactor. This enables you to validate that the behavior of the program hasn’t changed after refactoring. In our above example, you can create tests that provide different inputs to the `calculate_total_price()` method and validate the output against expected values.
Step 3: Refactor Code
Now that you’re confident with your safety net of tests, you can now start refactoring the code. In our example, we could better structure the code by breaking down the long method into smaller methods, each handling a single operation.
def calculate_price_before_discount(quantity, price_per_unit):
return quantity * price_per_unit
def apply_discount(total, discount):
return total – (total * discount / 100)
def apply_tax(total, tax):
return total + (total * tax / 100)
def calculate_total_price(quantity, price_per_unit, discount, tax):
total = calculate_price_before_discount(quantity, price_per_unit)
total = apply_discount(total, discount)
total = apply_tax(total, tax)
return total
Step 4: Rerun Tests
Upon refactoring the code, rerun your tests again. If all tests pass successfully, you can be confident that your refactoring has not altered the expected behavior of the system.
Step 5: Repeat
Refactoring is not a one-off process. As the software evolves and changes, there is constant need for refactoring.
Benefits of Refactoring
By refactoring, we can derive several tangible benefits for the maintainability of the system.
- Improved Readability: Breaking down a complex system into simpler parts improves readability. This facilitates understanding of the codebase for any new team members.
- Reduced Complexity: Complex systems are harder to maintain and update. By refactoring, we simplify systems, making it easier to perform updates and bug fixes.
- Easier Extensions: With a refactored codebase, it becomes simpler to add new features due to increased modularity.
Remember, continual refactoring is a shared responsibility among all team members and is crucial in developing a highly efficient and maintainable system. As the saying goes: “Leave the code better than you found it.”
Answer the Questions in Comment Section
True or False: Refactoring a system for maintainability involves improving the code without changing the external behavior of the system.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: Refactoring aims to improve the internal structure of the code, such as readability or reduce complexity, without altering its external behavior or functionality.
In the refactoring process, which of the following steps is NOT necessary?
- A. Identifying areas of the system for improvement
- B. Making small, incremental changes
- C. Testing after each change
- D. Adding new features to the system
Answer: D. Adding new features to the system
Explanation: Refactoring is about improving the design of existing code, not adding new features. While adding new features might be a part of system enhancement or upgrade, it is not part of the refactoring process.
True or False: Refactoring decreases the maintainability of a system.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: On the contrary, refactoring improves the maintainability of a system. It reduces the complexity of the code, makes it cleaner and easier to understand, which ultimately increases maintainability.
What is an example of a refactoring technique?
- A. Creating entirely new features
- B. Deleting unnecessary code
- C. Adding more complexity to the code
- D. Ignoring software bugs
Answer: B. Deleting unnecessary code
Explanation: Removing unnecessary or dead code is a refactoring technique that helps in reducing the complexity and increasing the maintainability of a system.
True or False: Automated testing is an integral part of the refactoring process.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: Automated testing is key to refactoring as it ensures the behavior of the system remains the same after changes have been made.
Which of these benefits may come from refactoring a system?
- A. Increases code complexity
- B. Increases effort required for maintenance
- C. Decreases project cost
- D. Decreases system performance
Answer: C. Decreases project cost
Explanation: By making the system more efficient and easier to understand, refactoring tends to decrease project cost in the long run by reducing the effort for maintenance.
True or False: Avoiding duplication or redundancy is a common goal when refactoring a system.
- True
- False
Answer: True
Explanation: Code duplication increases complexity and decreases maintainability. Therefore, refactoring often includes efforts to minimize or eliminate code duplication.
Which is NOT an acceptable reason to refactor a system?
- A. Improving code readability
- B. Improving code maintainability
- C. Removing unnecessary code duplication
- D. Making the system behave differently
Answer: D. Making the system behave differently
Explanation: Refactoring aims to improve the internal structure of the code without altering its external behavior.
What should be the first step to ensure successful refactoring?
- A. Code review
- B. Automated testing
- C. Incremental changes
- D. Discussing the changes with the team
Answer: B. Automated testing
Explanation: Automated testing should be the first step in refactoring to guarantee that the changes do not break the system.
True or False: Refactoring a system should always lead to performance improvement.
- True
- False
Answer: False
Explanation: While refactoring can sometimes lead to the improvement in performance, the primary goal of refactoring is to improve the understandability and maintainability of the code.
What does the principle “refactor early, refactor often” mean?
- A. Add new features as early as possible
- B. Refactor after each iteration
- C. Wait until the end of the project to refactor
- D. Make small refactoring steps as soon as the need is identified
Answer: D. Make small refactoring steps as soon as the need is identified
Explanation: This principle means that instead of waiting for the codebase to accumulate much technical debt, it’s beneficial to make small improvements as and when they are identified.
Great post! Refactoring for maintainability is crucial in a Scrum environment.
I totally agree. One approach that works well for me is the use of design patterns. Anyone else?
Appreciate the post. Clean code is easier to refactor for future needs.
One technique I’ve found useful is breaking down big classes into smaller, more manageable ones. Thoughts?
Thanks for the insightful article!
In my projects, I’ve used code reviews as a way to ensure maintainability. They help catch issues early on.
Wonderful post! Really enjoyed reading it.
This blog provides valuable insights. Regular refactoring ensures that technical debt is kept low.